Eragon Doesn’t Soar

I saw the movie Eragon over the holidays and was disappointed. Christopher Paolini, the young author, should be frustrated if he received a percentage deal for the movie rights because I don’t think it will do as well as the story deserves. The best parts of the book were, I think, the relationships between the characters. Like the friendship between Eragon and the dwarf Orik, or the fascinating meeting with Angela and her were-cat companion, or the conflict with the Varden’s Twins. These were practically, if not completely, nonexistent in the movie. Brom was reasonably played by Jeremy Irons (his characterization probably the closest to the Brom in the book but, believe me, the two are still far apart.)
If I had one criticism of the book I would say the magic comes too easily to Eragon. There should, I think, be a lot more to it. But in the movie, it’s absurd. It’s like ‘poof’ and he’s suddenly a magician.
This movie strikes me as a quick attempt at a money grab. The Potter fans flock to see their films so shouldn’t Eragon fans? But at least the Harry Potter films stay grounded in the main plot of the book. Eragon is just a departure from the book and not a particularly good one… just like the poor adaptations of Earthsea and Riverworld.
If you must see it, my advice is to wait until it’s cheap at your local DVD borrowing facility (it shouldn’t take long).  The way this one ends I have my doubts about how they’re going to tie in with the next book called Eldest and I wouldn’t pay to go see it either.


1 thought on “Eragon Doesn’t Soar”

  1. […] Brisingr 2008-12-16 Posted by tgrignon in Miscellany. Tags: book, Brisingr, Christopher Paolini, fantasy trackback Fire in the ancient language invented by Christopher Paolini is the name of the third book in his Inheritance Cycle of fantasy books. It is a transitional work and sets up all the elements for the unnamed fourth and final book: so while you learn some new things about Eragon and the dragons, it didn’t have as much an impact on me as the second book and especially the first. The background on the Urgals and the continuing of Roran’s adventures were, however, interesting.  Eragon is rebounding here, learning how to fight his brother and Galvatorix from his teacher.  I found the death at the end of the book too quick, however.  It seemed too much of a waste for someone of that calibre to my liking. I enjoyed it and certainly recommend it to anyone who has read the first two. Still, I doubt that making a movie with this or the second book would be a good idea. Paolini’s world was certainly too big for the producers and screen writers of the first movie. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s